
LeBron James, with his decision to play for the Heat, has just tarnished his NBA career, his NBA legacy, and has made sure that he will never, no matter what he does, be the best player of all time.
LeBron James is a smart guy, or at least I thought he was. He should know that he has the talent, the skills, and the statistics to become the best player of all time. If he knew this, if he really knew this, why sign with Miami?
Signing with Miami, shows his desperation, his worry that he'll never get the title that he's been looking for, for seven years. Playing for and suffering with the Cavaliers must have made him question his talent, made him think that he couldn't secure that legacy as the best ever without an overload of support. For some reason, he feels he needs to win a title right now, when he still has at least six dominant, and I mean dominant, years in him.
He could have had it all. The Knicks could have been
his team, the Bulls could have been
his team, the Nets, the Cavs, the Clippers (like that was ever an option), could have all been
his team, and he could have won multiple titles with them. LeBron took a team with the Cavaliers' relatively crappy supporting cast and for two years straight made them the best team in the league; imagine what he can do with a halfway decent, and even solid, group of teammates. Instead he'll go to a team that is undoubtedly under the ownership of Dwyane Wade - and will continue to be Wade's team no matter what James does - in order to win the championships he almost surely could have won with any of the other teams that were pursuing him. How can he be the best ever, if he's on a team that's not even his?
As a Knicks fan, if he had gone anywhere else but South Beach, I would have been mourning the fact that the Knicks had missed out on him, but now I'm just mourning for LeBron more than anything. If he went to say New York, or New Jersey or even Chicago, he would have the opportunity to become the best ever because he would be the main reason above all, why those teams would be winning. Any one of those three teams with LeBron could take down a Wade-Bosh Heat team that had few supporting players in a heartbeat. LeBron would be able to prove to the world that he is a true leader, and above all a winner.
I have gone on the record as saying that the Heat with James, Wade and Bosh can win up to eight titles. If you have the best player, the 3rd best player (the 2nd best player when Kobe retires) and one of the best young big men in the game, that you can't lose no matter who you surround yourself with. Everyone says you need role players to win titles. They talk about the Jordan years with guys like John Paxson, Toni Kukoc and so many more. Sure, Paxson and Kukoc played a nice role in the Bulls dynasty, but you don't think the Bulls would have been even better if you added a guy like Karl Malone to the mix? We only say you need role players, because first of all, we've never had a chance to see a team with the number of stars the Heat will have, and second because role players are always glorified because of the stars. Sure the Robert Horrys of the world may win you a few games in the playoffs with a clutch three, but had guys like himself, Rick Fox, and Devean George been replaced with Dirk Nowitzki, you're going to tell me that the Lakers would be worse off? Besides, it's not like these guys will have a bunch of nobodies surrounding them. Ring-less veterans will flock to this team in order to get what looks like a sure-fire title. They'll be able to get the role players, but I truly believe they don't need them.
With so many superstars and much less competition, the titles this Heat team wins will mean less than if they had done it with a regular supporting cast. It certainly won't mean less to their fans, but if will mean less for the Super Trio, James and Wade especially. Once the 31 year old Kobe starts to lose his talents, there will be no competition for this team. That's because you can make the argument that there's never been a team with three players as great as this. The 60s Celtics had Bill Russell, but Bob Cousy was on his way out, and the rest of the Celtics were great, including guys like John Havlicek and Tommy Heinsohn, but most of the team was made up of role players, and neither Havlicek nor Heinsohn were the third best player in the league like Wade was. The 80s Lakers had Magic Johnson, Kareem Abdul Jabbar, and James Worthy, which right now - may and that's a big may - top this trio. LeBron James and Dwyane Wade are two of the three best in the league at the same time, and are coming off arguably their best seasons, making this type of team truly unprecedented. If Bosh can play up to the standard many have set for him and continue to improve, there's no telling how good this team can be.
But, in the end, even if this team wins 8 titles, which certainly isn't extremely likely, is it really a big deal? By signing together, they took away from the competitiveness of the rest of the league. That's part of what really made Jordan the best ever, the fact that he was able to win multiple titles and perform at the highest level despite the competition he faced. Every year he had to go up against a Jazz team that had Malone and Stockton, a Magic team with Shaq and Hardaway, a Knicks team that had Ewing and Starks and Oakley. By teaming up with the best players in the league, it'll be tough to find a rival that can really compare to the talent the Heat now have.
LeBron first of all won't be able to have the ridiculous stats that he did in Cleveland, as there's only one ball to split between he, Wade and Bosh. Second of all, he copped out by signing with the Heat; instead of being a true competitor, and accepting the challenge of having to take down Bosh and Wade to get to the Finals by signing with another team, LeBron backed down and took the safe way out; Jordan never would have backed down, Jordan would have signed with the Knicks or Cavs or Nets, and made sure the world knew, that he was going to take every single team in the league down, because he knew in his heart that with his talent he could take on the Boshs and Wades of the world. That's why if you want to be the best, you have to have swagger, and attitude, and fearlessness, and not only do you have to make everyone know that you're the best, but you, yourself, have to know that you're the best. If LeBron truly believed he could be the best ever, there's no reason to have signed with the Heat.
The next decade in the NBA in my opinion, will be like baseball's Steroid Era: phony. The multiple titles that LeBron may win, will be exactly like the 762 homers that Barry Bonds hit during his career. Sure on paper Bonds may be the home run king, and possibly the best baseball player of all time, but we know it was all just because of steroids. Same thing with LeBron; when it's all said and done, he may have the titles to be the best, and even the numbers to be the best, but we'll know it was just because of the Super Trio he had. All of the championships he would win, the stats he would put up, would always have an asterisk next to it because of the players he played with.
For a guy with LeBron's talent, championships are only part of the road to becoming the best ever. A good amount of players have won a lot of championships, but only one man can be considered the best ever, and LeBron sacrificed the chance of being one of a kind for the easy road to winning championships, something he could have done without Bosh and Wade.
The sad part of this whole thing is that he has the potential to be as good if not better than Jordan. LeBron, at such a young age, and with so much fanfare showed us all how good he was and unlimited potential that he had. He is the youngest player ever to reach every point-based milestone that he has gotten to so far, the last being 15,000 points. He is the youngest player to have a triple double in one game, accomplishing the feat at the young age of 20 years and 20 days old. He is an unstoppable 6'8", 260 pound behemoth that could have ruled the game of basketball and been the true King. Instead he listened to the critics, listened to the fans, the people whispering in his ear, wondering when LeBron was going to get that first title, if he ever was going to get it. Instead of puffing out his chest and sticking it to everyone, showing people around the world, that he was the boss and that they better get used to it, he ran away from the challenge, chickened out from the expectations that he had been living up to so far throughout his career.
He's not a quitter for quitting on the Cavaliers. He tried to stay in Cleveland, held on for as long as he could; you don't think LeBron would love to win a title for his hometown more than anything in the world? But there was no hope there anymore, not even a bright spot on the horizon. The Cavaliers did all they could and LeBron did all he could and it was never enough. What is he supposed to do? You want him to wait for old age to set in and look on, while Wade and Bosh are winning the titles he could have won? LeBron doesn't owe anyone anything. Not the Knicks, not the Bulls, not the Nets and especially not the Cavaliers. In a recent article, ESPN's Gene Wojciechowski compared LeBron's free agency to the Brett Favre circus, calling him out for "jacking around" the other teams he was thinking about signing with. Gene couldn't be more wrong. LeBron never made any promises like Brett Favre, didn't keep us waiting for months on end like Brett Favre, didn't even have a Twitter until during this whole masquerade He kept his mouth shut until his decision was made, didn't decide on one team then change his mind, like Brett Favre did going back and forth on retirement. Sure the special may have been a bit too much, but anything else wouldn't have sufficed as a finale to the media, fan-frenzy monster, that the fans and media have made out of this. I don't blame people for going crazy over free agency, and making it the soap opera it's become, but I also don't blame LeBron, for giving people what they truly wanted. If people really didn't want this, they would have just checked for the breaking news on ESPN.com instead of being one of the millions that watched the special. They still would have found out immediately. But, here's the thing, whether we like to admit it or not: we like excitement and we love drama in this country, especially in soap-opera form, and LeBron, no matter how self-centered he may seem, had the right to have his own special with all of the attention that WE have given HIM and this process over the past two years.
And while we're at it, above all, I have a bone to pick with Cavaliers owner Dan Gilbert. In a letter to Cavs fans, Gilbert went off on LeBron, using words like "cowardly betrayal, selfishness, [another] betrayal." Woah woah woah, hold up a second. LeBron didn't choose the Cavs, they chose him. He gave every ounce of heart he had to Cleveland, while he could have complained and whined about never having enough support, never getting enough help from management, etc. etc. Then I would certainly call him a diva, but he never did any of that. Every year he went about his business and did more than anyone else could have done with that team, and Dan Gilbert is a fool for disparaging LeBron after all he did for that city and team and all the money he made for Gilbert. Without James, the Cavaliers and Cleveland would have been nothing, and they should be damn grateful, that he even gave them a chance to re-sign him, that he even gave them the time of day, after they never gave him a chance to win. If the city of Cleveland doesn't appreciate what LeBron did for their entire city, then you can be sure I'll be smiling while the sports of Cleveland and the city of Cleveland bite the dust for the next few decades.
So LeBron James didn't fake anyone out, didn't quit on Cleveland or New York or any other city or team. LeBron James did something much worse than that though, by quitting on himself, on the expectations that he set for himself and that he could have achieved had he signed with a team that could have been his and his only, and that he could lead to greatness.
So sure, LeBron may be happy for now, winning titles with ease, destroying teams like no other team has done before, but if he doesn't leave Miami, when it's all said and done, he, as well as many others, will look back and wonder what could have been had he accepted the challenge, had he taken the leap of faith that he needed to in order to reach basketball immortality. The man that may have been basketball's best chance of ever matching His Airness gave up just like that, and now we'll never know what could have been.